AIP-1, AIP-2, AIP-7, the template and the index brought to the working generation: the published governance text was missing entire sections, including the rules themselves (D-377)

This commit is contained in:
Aere Network committed 2026-09-11 22:04:15 +03:00
1 parent 16ce7e8989
commit 83453d9a79
5 files changed
+461 -233

No files matched your search

+44 -17
View File
@@ -12,34 +12,22 @@
| Status | Final |
| Created | 2026-07-11 |
| Requires | None |
| Supersedes | None |
| Superseded-By | None |
| Ratification | Foundation-ratified (pre-decentralization) |
## Abstract
This AIP documents the on-chain mechanism that makes AERE's burn real and
This AIP documents the on-chain mechanism that makes AERE's fee-burn real and
auditable: an atomic splitter that routes a validator's accumulated coinbase
rewards so that a fixed fraction, 37.5% by default, is sent to a permanent burn
vault and the remainder is returned to the validator. It is a retro-filed record
of a change that is already live on chain 2800.
**Realized burn to date, MEASURED.** The mechanism is live and the vault is
immutable, and it has burned essentially nothing. `eth_getBalance` on the burn
vault `0x696afDF4f814e6Fd6aa45CE14C498ed9375fB2c6` returned
`0x1e7f974e119aaa7` at block 10,571,949 on 2026-07-20, which is
137,352,594,046,167,719 wei, or 0.1373525940461677 AERE, against a fixed supply
of 2,800,000,000 AERE. The reason is arithmetic: the burn is a percentage of
validator coinbase revenue, that revenue is currently zero, and a percentage of
zero is zero. The 37.5% in this document is a conditional rate on future
revenue. AERE is not deflationary today. Verify with one RPC call.
## Motivation
The AERE whitepaper (Section 3.3) states that up to 37.5% of transaction fees are
permanently removed from circulation. That wording predates the implemented
mechanism and is superseded: what this AIP specifies, and what is live, is a cut
of the VALIDATOR COINBASE REWARD, not of transaction fees. The
validator-reward-cut description governs everywhere the two conflict. On a
Hyperledger Besu QBFT chain there is no
permanently removed from circulation. On a Hyperledger Besu QBFT chain there is no
protocol-level base-fee burn of the EIP-1559 kind: QBFT credits fees to the block
proposer's coinbase rather than burning any part of them at the consensus layer.
So the whitepaper claim needed an explicit, on-chain mechanism, or it would be
@@ -137,7 +125,46 @@ All addresses copied verbatim from `sdk-js/src/addresses.ts`. Live cumulative
burn statistics are readable via `AereCoinbaseSplitter.burnStats()` and
`AereFeeBurnVault.totalBurnedAERE()`.
## Errata
None.
## Post-Acceptance Outcome Record
*Appended 2026-07-20 under AIP-1 section 5. Nothing above this heading was
edited. This record exists because the mechanism works exactly as specified while
producing an economic outcome that a reader of the sections above would not
predict.*
**The burn is real and it is approximately zero.**
| Quantity | Value | Provenance |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Burn rate | 37.5% of the validator coinbase reward | spec (configured) |
| Hard cap on the rate | 50% (`setBurnBps` reverts above `5000`) | spec |
| Coinbase revenue to date | zero | measured |
| Lifetime burned | 0.1374 AERE | measured |
The splitter routes 37.5% of what it receives, and it has received almost
nothing, because the chain is quiet and coinbase revenue is effectively zero. A
percentage of zero is zero. The mechanism is live, immutable at its endpoints,
and verifiable; the supply effect is negligible.
**Therefore AERE is not deflationary today, and no Aere document may say that it
is.** A burn mechanism existing is not the same claim as supply decreasing, and
the difference between those two claims is 0.1374 AERE against a 2.8 billion
supply. This will change only if transaction volume changes; it is not a
parameter anyone can tune, because the rate is already set and the input is what
is missing.
**Two related confusions to keep out of Aere copy.** First, this burn is a cut of
the **validator coinbase reward**, not an EIP-1559 base-fee burn; QBFT credits
fees to the proposer's coinbase and burns nothing at the consensus layer, which is
why the mechanism is a contract above consensus. Second, chain 2800 does separately
run a 1 Gwei base-fee **floor** from block 10,141,734 (AIP-17); a floor sets a
minimum price and removes no supply. Conflating the floor with the burn produces a
statement that is wrong twice.
## Copyright
Released to the public domain (CC0). No rights reserved.
</content>